Skip to main content

Do friends violate encapsulation?


FAQ: On the contrary - they enhance it. If used properly, of course.

For example, you can use them to split code into two classes and have their data inaccessible for code in all other classes. Or you can use them as "a syntactic variant" of member functions.

Think of the friends as part of the class interface instead of something outside the class.

FQA: What encapsulation? C++ doesn't have encapsulation. It has access control (code outside of a class using private members of this class will not compile), but it has neither compile time encapsulation (stable binary interfaces) nor run time encapsulation (safe memory access). What's there to violate?

The case of two classes was discussed in the previous FAQ; this argument only sounds convincing if you think C++ classes are a good way to define the important, stable interfaces in your system.

As to the "syntactic variant" business, it's probably about overloaded operators. The C++ syntax makes it impossible to define overloaded operators as class members unless the first argument is an object of the class. Since C++ uses stream<<obj to print things, many classes declare a friend operator<<, for example. This argument is only interesting if you think C++ operator overloading is any good.
Labels:

Popular posts from this blog

C++ Program to find the sum, difference, product and quotient of two integers

#include <iostream.h> #include <conio.h> void main() {   clrscr();   int x = 10;   int y = 2;   int sum, difference, product, quotient;   sum = x + y;   difference = x - y;   product = x * y;   quotient = x / y;   cout << "The sum of " << x << " & " << y << " is " << sum << "." << endl;   cout << "The difference of " << x << " & " << "y <<  is " << difference << "." << endl;   cout << "The product of " << x << " & " << y << " is " << product << "." << endl;   cout << "The quotient of " << x << " & " << y << " is " << quotient << "." << endl;   getch(); }
Read more

Program of virtual piano

//////////////Tested And Created By C++/////////////////////////////// #include<stdio.h> #include<dos.h> #include<conio.h> #include<stdlib.h> #define SHOW 1 #define HIDE 2 union REGS input,output; class piano {  public:int BIGKEY,MIDKEY,back,border;     piano()//init constructor     {         BIGKEY=15;         MIDKEY=1;         back=7;         border=15;     } }color; void drawpiano(int x,int y); int check_xy(int x,int y); void BOX(int c,int r,int c1,int r1,int col); int initmouse(); void setupscreen(); void pointer(int on); void restrictmouse(int x1,int y1,int x2,int y2); void check_keys(int x,int y); void getmouse(int *button,int *x,int *y); float freq[7] = {130.81, 146.83, 164.81, 174.61,196, 220, 246.94 } ; int n=0,a=4,backcolor=2,exitcode=1; void showbar(int t) {  if(t>65) t=65;  if(t<1) t=1;  textcolor(15);  for(int q=0;q<=t;t++)  {     gotoxy(3+q,4);     cprintf("Û");  } } void main() {  int
Read more

Putimage function in c

putimage function outputs a bit image onto the screen. Declaration:- void putimage(int left, int top, void *ptr, int op); putimage puts the bit image previously saved with getimage back onto the screen, with the upper left corner of the image placed at (left, top). ptr points to the area in memory where the source image is stored. The op argument specifies a operator that controls how the color for each destination pixel on screen is computed, based on pixel already on screen and the corresponding source pixel in memory. c smiling face animation This animation using c draws a smiling face which appears at random position on screen. See output below the code, it will help you in understanding the code easily. C programming code #include<graphics.h> #include<conio.h> #include<stdlib.h>   main() { int gd = DETECT, gm, area, temp1, temp2, left = 25, top = 75; void *p;   initgraph(&gd,&gm,"C:\\TC\\BGI");   setcolor(YELLOW);
Read more